[200William-EC SP67851] Fwd: FW: SP67851 - WATER PENETRATION

[Barney Kitay]

Do we have any options in terms of insurance claim from Big Corp? or are
we past that? 

---

Kind Regards

_Barney_
m: +61 (0)400 200 446
e: barnet at kitays.com

==================================================

On 22-05-2014 09:16, Matt Perkins wrote: 

> Thanks Brook. I am inclined to agree that something needs to be done. If it were my place that was flooded every time I went on holidays I would want something fixed. We have also set a president in fixing Barney's. The value of the quote however will put the budget well into special the levy zone. I also wonder how many other balcony's are in this state. 
> 
> We are also open to the department of fair trading forcing our hand if they consider it to be outside specifications. 
> 
> George is it possible to get some advice as to how many other balcony's may be in this state. 
> 
> Matt.
> 
> On 22/05/14 9:00 AM, Brook Beves wrote: 
> 
>> Good morning all and thanks Matt for prompting a response to this issue. 
>> 
>> You are correct in stating that my balcony has been constructed incorrectly in that during rain downpours water falls towards my unit lounge room sliding doors and it pools there until I sweep/mop it away towards the drain overflow. If the unit is left unattended, which it is regularly, the water just lies there. 
>> 
>> During the latter part of March I was absent for a week. When I returned rain water had penetrated the balcony floor membrane and had seeped through the south/east corner wall into the lounge room causing internal water damage. 
>> 
>> Thanks to Georges prompt response arrangements were made to water test/inspect the balcony, the results of which have been forwarded to you all with remedial recommendations. 
>> 
>> Whilst I acknowledge the costs factors, I believe Option 1 is a bandaid solution to a disaster waiting to happen, in that rain water will still pool and eventually break down the balcony membrane or overflow and again penetrate the unit. I note your comment Barney that at some stage your balcony was ripped up 3 times. 
>> 
>> I support the remedial work detailed in Option 2 of the quotes and look forward to your collective thoughts. 
>> 
>> Many thanks 
>> 
>> Brook 
>> 
>> -------------------------
>> 
>> FROM: ec-bounces at 200william.com [mailto:ec-bounces at 200william.com] ON BEHALF OF Matt Perkins
>> SENT: Wednesday, 21 May 2014 8:51 AM
>> TO: ec at 200william.com
>> SUBJECT: [200William-EC SP67851] Fwd: FW: SP67851 - WATER PENETRATION 
>> 
>> Hi All,
>> George has asked that we resolve this one. This is the water leaks on Brook's balcony. The short story is the balcony has been constructed incorrectly and the water falls toward his apartment instead of toward the overflow. A result is it's possible under some conditions to flood the balcony and ultimately his apartment. 
>> 
>> George (and im sure Brook) would like a resolution as to what our action should be so he can close this job. 
>> 
>> Your thoughts. 
>> 
>> Matt.
>> 
>> FROM: George Ziri 
>> SENT: Friday, 16 May 2014 8:51 PM
>> TO: ec at 200william.com
>> SUBJECT: SP67851 - WATER PENETRATION 
>> 
>> All, 
>> 
>> Attached is report and summary for the repairs to 402 balcony. 
>> 
>> The report provides two options is self explanatory. 
>> 
>> Option 1 repairs the issue at hand. 
>> 
>> Option 2 is for the renewal of the entire balcony. During rain water falls back to the hob rather to the drain. This is an aesthetics issue and does not cause an issue to the apartment interior. This would be something that would need to be discussed amongst each other. 
>> 
>> I cant not recommend what option the Executive Committee to make. I would prefer Tony Tesererio carry out the repairs as he carried out the tests. However Empire building services is also another contractor which I'm also content with and recommend. 
>> 
>> GEORGE ZIRI 
>> 
>> OPERATIONS ! &nbs p; 
>> 
>> BUILDING FACILITIES MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS 
>> 
>> M: 0400 300 242 
>> 
>> E: georgeziri at bfms.com.au W: www.bfms.com.au [1] 
>> 
>> Safety | Integrity | Service | Excellence
> 
> -- 
> /* Matt Perkins 
> Direct 1300 137 379 Spectrum Networks Ptd. Ltd. 
> Office 1300 133 299 matt at spectrum.com.au 
> Fax 1300 133 255 Level 6, 350 George Street Sydney 2000
> SIP 1300137379 at sip.spectrum.com.au 
> PGP/GNUPG Public Key can be found at http://pgp.mit.edu [2] 
> */
> 
> _______________________________________________
> EC mailing list
> EC at 200william.com
> http://200william.com/mailman/listinfo/ec [3]
 

Links:
------
[1]
http://u361747.sendgrid.org/wf/click?upn=paAuoSyhP986EecDgeXXTAPtCf8r8OAnKY0JBkSJh-2FCQG-2FHRXXzW3uTJ5xlck4raSNn-2B6yczCqvE9dzu0S2pJ9JvUVoehU24fTL-2FNu5fx-2FH0-2FxR71Cm0jpl-2FKvYH-2F0k4LfHrezjwhDPExfcSmWNC6JlAYdS1zG6CjJDSiUIyvxYl7XeMW3xQjvVX7llwBnuqnWabcXNrlpHITBHle9VlVrwNM22c0yog75oQwFYPjNvrG9RKMiuLv8VqbUDcdC9bzaTInVLU9m4QQ3-2BWfwquKyk-2ByDApPlj0lJjzQMTspps-2BKbdguB4w8CCg-2BEknmMn0Xs7qdKRBsoi6ri6FcyPgKvTZH9SLaaj46EYf7yhVUZYk7O87sVGWzEjubUC5umWj47Acjx6U1tQZlU7IT1xKV1xuIuTSDil3simoUOXtEof6Le07CawpkFZd31bWPC7sx5gVvrbjfI-2BbbPR9yE7xB7L-2FxhOPkd7YYwEfVo5i0T9vZAdmwuS4h0Xm6mQbaTHRi3phjgoj-2FIfdouilwBU2zJ5BDsLb-2BPXfJ25q-2Bz0WBozFxs8KY71RG5myKIgJBbTPuXGc6kLFgsg59uX9VN-2FaG36vwnCBkcl3DQUenaKgeiTr0B8h2efSWIgsc2-2FBoroF0rriJIXs4jNrWW5q4VmwdfDtiNhlk8X2kTSYPbLFiaHRFywGZPhI-2Fzh3h1ihTKLtoeWiny5xpz7kjgZQN1mYgdXtb2WXHwl1QJCuu-2FIITPIG9CD-2BRbxXtrxUHQMDxsvuBZKEmlOjCpTpdBraG3cfs3RsYyoKmu-2FLwycaV-2FIut-2BOyvq-2FMeCfeTlBvwoVqKqGKWKmarjd1fqi6Nm0E-2Fu2nu2ptMtkxI-2BwZ61ZVetCtfbVMZQpXc-2Ban!%21%0!
 d%0a%20FK
pl9xywnA%0d%0aDfzhYozOnDTieRIvRu7XtoC2MhWKyDIdrXr4JrvzVzvfSu6Ic-2FDD56alsl5FgoMEz5XZxfZAJAyXr1Ynk4GIJ8xRF-2Ft0JED4YMGI8SmYsMNzm5wL8t0H5C3eqysn1tQiHsrJ2UCE4lWYhri-2FbJq6I-2BBZitulSi0GOptBm0mD3ZKX6HoR0uAxxCymzmr4P1gvoo0kESiVSh-2B1fPN12zcv8sYhKjOx15ZOTANiJoht1y9Cj4GUdEy4jCazQ67CMnCdvM-2B-2F7Dq55-2BsvTExhhtVLOqQ4SVi2Z8vbQ0SpHUg7l7EWqh7tRf4E4wJHBtDzSiMkVPRHmfXEbm9mpdbFNHDPzzhmEdgbkgRdLJTtffdcNhiC7U7XipY2EkrAq-2FklAvGQo6jarR0C4LTSEoOp-2FFGQ5dE-2FDnJKkvGUYPufRIMekOwm5RzkOzrBfz-2F-2Fx-2BCU-2Ft8ynR1670cUmCJ9DxKfc1VousIpAMEiMzgOJtSbwwrwWEpxUpre7MUs7LSTrGrwtrOw56TrV3N8sxBo59j5JxDA3cSKHRJYW-2FB-2BCvrlVbQ9LxTuiGb8MQEF9AwAxDWJVyr4DWD9OUATidGia-2BO-2Fu3Lk-2F0RgvpzmujxysG0CIQVCRL6sRovm6IiSDRqNkDAqRi9lQDJfivWLdHVOiX9YaJ-2F0TeZNgh9E4pc5PRIlwXv88H1rrimdKuCkElEa-2FH3c1N9F4I5VRQDXlK5tRkPDq6D934ru7Wf2ZsX-2Bwuvl-2FqSHtRNn-2FFitl0qFpuc49Py7rbgphypTrmZw7YIOrA2zT0A5Wk1ILsVGS4mV-2B-2F11TfRbD56ItRmOkpieDRDI-2Bsy2bHyFz-2BLfN1XyI2IAhjAJ6P6ZDBP9hyikFiTiyltaL4gKWR6ur5mtO3oPqONEkwQCyseXAo4bGsjGeyD0O5m9Q!9pC!
 Ka-2FXmX-
2Fq9V-%21%0d%0a%202BsJGkmNGs%0d%0aRohnmIU12WbWDgrAbpKYaMrL48cCHlnQS4Osx4-2BuqltTcS3CDfIdV-2Fm6VIhz4Yjsn0lbQbEbD7IF
[2] http://pgp.mit.edu
[3] http://200william.com/mailman/listinfo/ec
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://200william.com/mailman/private/ec/attachments/20140522/734b32e5/attachment-0001.html